Unregistered property transfer and capital gains valuation: section 50C adjustment sustained in part, with DVO-based recomputation required.

Capital gains on an unregistered transfer of immovable property were to be computed on a legally supportable full value of consideration, and the section 50C issue depended on the relevant statutory position for the assessment year. Where the stamp valuation authority had not adopted a value, the Departmental Valuation Officer's estimate under section 55A could be used for the office premises, subject to a further 10% reduction accepted on the assessee's objection. The Assessing Officer was also required to verify the correct opening book value. The entire addition could not be deleted; instead, the capital-gain addition was sustained only in part and had to be recomputed accordingly.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether the addition to capital gains computed by applying section 50C on unregistered transfer of immovable properties was sustainable, and whether the valuation made with reference to stamp duty/DVO report required modification.

Analysis: The transfer of immovable assets was admitted, but the properties were not registered, so the stamp valuation authority had not adopted any value. The controversy turned on whether the word "assessable" inserted in section 50C could be applied for the relevant assessment year, and whether the Departmental Valuation Officer's estimate could be accepted for the office premises. The computation under section 48 had to proceed on the basis of a legally supportable full value of consideration. The valuation issue was treated as technical, and the DVO reference under section 55A was accepted for the office premises, while the assessee's objection justified an additional 10% deduction from the DVO's valuation. The Assessing Officer was also directed to verify the correct opening book value for the relevant property.

Conclusion: The deletion of the entire addition was not sustainable. The capital-gain addition was restored in part, with further reduction directed in respect of valuation, and the Assessing Officer was required to rework the figures accordingly.

Final Conclusion: The revenue succeeded only to a limited extent, as the matter was partly restored for recomputation of capital gains on the basis indicated by the Tribunal.

Ratio Decidendi: For an unregistered transfer, the applicability of section 50C must depend on the relevant statutory position, and where valuation is otherwise supported by a DVO reference, the computation of capital gains may be sustained with appropriate adjustment to reflect the correct fair market value.

---