Reconnection charges for pager reactivation form part of taxable service value when tied to the same radio paging service.

Reconnection charges collected for reactivating pagers after expiry of the initial subscription period were treated as part of the value of the same radio paging service for service tax purposes. The charges were not regarded as a separate or extraneous receipt, and the Ministry circular dated 20-12-2000 was read as dealing with surcharge rather than reconnection charges. On that basis, the charges fell within the taxable service value and the challenge to their inclusion failed.

---

---

Issues: Whether reconnection charges collected from subscribers for reactivation of pagers after expiry of the initial subscription period formed part of the value of the taxable service for service tax purposes.

Analysis: The authorities below had recorded that the reconnection charges were collected in relation to the same radio paging service and were not a separate, extraneous receipt. The order also noted that the Ministry's circular dated 20-12-2000 dealt with surcharge and not with reconnection charges. On that basis, the charges were treated as falling within the taxable service value.

Conclusion: The reconnection charges were rightly included in the taxable value, and the challenge failed.

---