Discharge stage limits require only a prima facie assessment; courts cannot weigh rival evidence before trial.

At the discharge stage, the court may only assess whether the prosecution material discloses a prima facie case, and may sift material only for that limited purpose. It cannot conduct a detailed appreciation of evidence, resolve rival versions, or prefer one set of statements over another before trial, especially where evidence has not been tested by cross-examination. The Supreme Court held that the High Court erred in weighing investigation statements at discharge, so the discharge order was premature and unsustainable and was set aside.

---

---

Issues: Whether the High Court could discharge the accused by appreciating and weighing the statements collected during investigation at the stage of consideration of discharge.

Analysis: At the stage of discharge, the court is required to form only a limited judicial assessment whether the material placed by the prosecution discloses a prima facie case. The material may be sifted and weighed only for that limited purpose, but the court cannot undertake a detailed appreciation of evidence, resolve rival versions on trustworthiness, or prefer one set of statements over another before trial. Where the evidence is yet to be tested by cross-examination, competing versions cannot be conclusively assessed and the question whether the accused should face trial must be determined on the basis of the prosecution material as it stands.

Conclusion: The High Court erred in undertaking appreciation of evidence at the discharge stage, and its order discharging the accused was premature and unsustainable.

Final Conclusion: The order of discharge was set aside and the matter was restored to proceed in accordance with law at trial.

Ratio Decidendi: At the stage of discharge, the court may only determine whether the prosecution material discloses a prima facie case and cannot conduct a full appreciation of evidence or choose between rival factual versions before trial.

---