Yield-based land compensation must avoid double valuation, and the correct multiplier is essential when assessing fruit-bearing trees.

Compensation for acquired land and fruit-bearing trees cannot be valued separately in a way that results in double assessment of the land's worth. Where market value is determined on a yield basis, a suitable multiplier must be applied; the text notes an 8-year multiplier for fruit-bearing trees and a 12-year multiplier for agricultural land. It also states that the High Court enhanced compensation without correcting the valuation method or the multiplier adopted by the Collector, and that further enhancement on the basis of price index was unjustified. The reference court's award was restored and the High Court's enhancement was set aside.

---

---

Issues: Whether compensation for acquired land with fruit-bearing trees could be separately enhanced on the basis of the trees after determining land value on yield basis, and whether the correct multiplier was applied in fixing compensation.

Analysis: The compensation for acquired land and fruit-bearing trees must not be assessed separately so as to value the land twice over. Where market value is determined on the basis of yield, a suitable multiplier has to be applied, and for fruit-bearing trees the appropriate multiplier is 8 years, while agricultural land may justify a 12 years multiplier. The High Court enhanced compensation without correcting the erroneous valuation method and without addressing the improper multiplier adopted by the Collector. Since the Collector's award could not be reduced below the amount offered, the High Court's further enhancement on the basis of price index was unjustified.

Conclusion: The separate enhancement of compensation for the fruit-bearing trees was illegal, and the State's challenge succeeded.

Final Conclusion: The award of the reference court was restored and the High Court's enhancement was set aside, leaving the parties to bear their own costs.

Ratio Decidendi: Compensation for acquired land and fruit-bearing trees cannot be separately valued in a manner that results in double assessment of the land's worth, and when valuation proceeds on yield basis the appropriate multiplier must be applied.

---