Framing of charge requires overall scrutiny of police report material and excludes extraneous documents from consideration.

At the stage of framing of charge in a case instituted on a police report, the court must assess prima facie involvement on an overall appreciation of the investigation materials, not by isolating individual allegations. The court also must confine itself to the material forming part of the police report record under Section 173 CrPC and cannot rely on extraneous documents whose authenticity has not been examined. Applying that approach, the discharge was unsustainable because the lower court treated the matter as mere negligence and relied on letters outside the admissible record; the matter had to be reconsidered on the proper material.

---

---

Issues: Whether the respondents were wrongly discharged at the stage of framing of charge by assessing the material in isolation and by relying upon letters not forming part of the police report record.

Analysis: At the stage of framing of charge, the court must assess whether the record discloses a prima facie case on an overall consideration of the materials collected during investigation. The respondents' alleged omission to perform mandatory duties could not be evaluated in isolation, and the court below erred in treating the matter as mere negligence. The court below also wrongly relied upon letters said to have been written by one respondent because, in a case based on a police report, the court must confine itself to the documents referred to under Section 173 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, and could not rely on documents whose authenticity and veracity had not been examined.

Conclusion: The discharge was unsustainable and the matter had to be reconsidered afresh on the basis of the proper record.

Ratio Decidendi: At the stage of framing of charge in a case instituted on a police report, the court must confine itself to the material forming part of the police report record and determine prima facie involvement on an overall appreciation of the investigation materials, without relying on extraneous documents.

---