Non-yielding agricultural land must be excluded when computing the exemption threshold under Karnataka agricultural income-tax rules.

Land bearing commercial crops or plants that have not yet reached the stage of yielding income is excluded when computing the exemption limit under the Karnataka Agricultural Income-tax Act, 1957. The charging provision and the relevant schedule proviso show that agricultural income-tax is not payable where the assessable land does not exceed the statutory acreage limit, and the same legislative intent is reflected in the composition provision dealing with non-yielding plants. The two provisions operate in different fields, but both require non-yielding land to be left out of the assessable extent. On that basis, the remaining land fell below the exemption threshold and the assessee was not liable.

---

---

Issues: Whether land covered with commercial crops that had not yet started yielding income was to be excluded while determining the exemption limit under the Karnataka Agricultural Income-tax Act, 1957.

Analysis: The charging provision read with proviso (ii) of Part I of the Schedule shows that agricultural income-tax is not payable by a person whose agricultural income is derived from land not exceeding fifty acres of the relevant class. The exclusion for plants or trees which have not reached the stage of yielding, though expressly found in the composition provision under section 67(5), reflects the same legislative intent as the proviso in the Schedule. The two provisions operate in different fields, but both indicate that land not yet yielding crop or income should not be counted against the assessee for the relevant statutory limit.

Conclusion: The non-yielding four acres had to be excluded while determining whether the assessee was assessable, and the remaining land fell below the exemption threshold.

Final Conclusion: The petitions succeeded and the assessment orders were restored.

Ratio Decidendi: For determining the statutory exemption limit under the agricultural income-tax scheme, land bearing crops or plants that have not yet reached the stage of yielding income is excluded from the assessable extent.

---