Estate duty valuation turns on once-only exemptions, accrued interest inclusion, situs-based asset value, and no deduction for estate duty.

Exemptions under the estate duty provisions are available only once, so relief already allowed for one house property cannot be claimed again for another property or its household articles. Accrued interest on fixed deposits is treated as part of the estate up to the date of death, subject to verification of the correct amount. For fixed deposits lying in Ceylon, valuation is based on the asset's market value at its situs, without deducting charges relevant only on remittance to India. Estate duty payable after death is not a deductible debt or encumbrance of the deceased.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether exemptions under sections 33(1)(n) and 33(1)(c) of the Estate Duty Act, 1953 were admissible again in computing the deceased's share in the second house property when full exemption had already been allowed in respect of another house property; (ii) Whether interest on fixed deposits had accrued up to the date of death so as to be includible in the principal value of the estate; (iii) Whether a deduction towards foreign exchange entitlement certificate charges was admissible in valuing fixed deposits lying in Ceylon; (iv) Whether estate duty payable was deductible in computing the principal value of the estate.

Issue (i): Whether exemptions under sections 33(1)(n) and 33(1)(c) of the Estate Duty Act, 1953 were admissible again in computing the deceased's share in the second house property when full exemption had already been allowed in respect of another house property.

Analysis: The exemptions under sections 33(1)(n) and 33(1)(c) were held to be available only once. Since the deceased's share in the Madras house property had already enjoyed the full statutory relief, the same benefit could not be claimed again in relation to Courtallam house property and its household articles.

Conclusion: The claim for a second exemption was not admissible and the finding was in favour of the Revenue.

Issue (ii): Whether interest on fixed deposits had accrued up to the date of death so as to be includible in the principal value of the estate.

Analysis: The distinction between accrual of interest and the date of payment was emphasised. Interest on invested deposits ordinarily accrues day by day even if payable only on maturity, so accrued interest up to the date of death formed part of the estate. The exact quantum, however, required factual verification as to whether the deposits continued till maturity or were withdrawn earlier.

Conclusion: Accrued interest was includible in the estate, subject to determination of the correct amount after inquiry, and the issue was decided in favour of the Revenue.

Issue (iii): Whether a deduction towards foreign exchange entitlement certificate charges was admissible in valuing fixed deposits lying in Ceylon.

Analysis: The principal value of the estate had to be determined with reference to the market value of the asset where it was situate. Since estate duty attached to the asset in Ceylon itself, the impediments or charges that might arise only on remittance to India were irrelevant for valuation purposes.

Conclusion: The deduction was not admissible and the issue was decided against the accountable person.

Issue (iv): Whether estate duty payable was deductible in computing the principal value of the estate.

Analysis: Estate duty arises only after death and is not a debt or encumbrance created by the deceased during lifetime. It therefore does not fall within the class of deductible liabilities contemplated by section 44 of the Estate Duty Act, 1953.

Conclusion: Estate duty payable was not deductible and the issue was decided against the accountable person.

Final Conclusion: The references were answered substantially in favour of the Revenue, with the unresolved hypothetical adoption question left unanswered.

Ratio Decidendi: Exemptions under the estate duty provisions are not repeatable for multiple properties once fully availed; interest on deposits accrues day by day; valuation of assets for estate duty is based on their situs market value; and estate duty payable after death is not a deductible debt or encumbrance of the deceased.

---