Business loss treatment denied for embezzled funds once credited to the assessee's bank account and misappropriated later.

Embezzlement by a munim after funds had been credited to the assessee's bank account was not deductible as a trading loss or under section 10(2)(xv). The tribunal distinguished losses occurring in the ordinary course before money reaches the business's control from misappropriation after the money has come into the assessee's hands for business purposes. Although the munim had wide authority under a general power of attorney and operated the account, the withdrawal of funds for his personal liabilities did not make the loss a business loss. The Madras authority cited was distinguished because, on its facts, the money had not yet reached the till before misappropriation.

---

---

Issues: Whether the amount embezzled by the assessee's munim and written off after partial recovery was deductible either as a business loss or under the general principles for computing business profits, including under section 10(2)(XV) of the Indian Income-tax Act.

Analysis: The assessment year was 1946-47 and the relevant accounting year was 1944-45. The munim had been entrusted with wide powers under a general power of attorney and withdrew money from the assessee's bank account for his personal liabilities. The Court distinguished losses caused by subordinates intercepting funds in the ordinary course of business from losses occurring after the money had reached the owner's control. It held that once the money had been credited to the assessee's bank account, it had reached the assessee for business purposes. The misappropriation was therefore not a trading loss merely because the munim had the authority to operate the account. The Madras decision relied on by the assessee was distinguished on the ground that, there, the funds had not reached the till before misappropriation.

Conclusion: The amount of Rs. 2,02,442-13-9 was not allowable as a deduction either as a business loss or under section 10(2)(XV) of the Indian Income-tax Act.

---