Independent audit and compliance verification may be ordered where share transfers and asset sales are seriously disputed and records are incomplete.

Where the legality and financial effect of transfers of shares and company assets are seriously disputed, and the record is incomplete, the NCLT may direct independent audit and compliance verification before final adjudication. The petitioners were found to satisfy the qualifying shareholding requirement and raised substantive concerns over valuation, accounting treatment, ownership of property, treatment of sale proceeds, and compliance with the company's constitutional and statutory requirements. Because later financial records were not produced and the factual position required independent verification, the Tribunal granted interim investigative relief and ordered appointment of an independent auditor and a practising company secretary to examine valuation, shareholding details, accounting entries, and statutory compliance.

---

---

Issues: Whether the petitioners were entitled to seek reliefs in respect of the company affairs, and whether an independent auditor and a practising company secretary should be appointed to examine the valuation, accounting treatment, and compliance relating to the transfer of shares and sale of company assets.

Analysis: The petitioners satisfied the qualifying shareholding requirement and raised substantive allegations that the company's shares and assets had been dealt with without adequate compliance with the company's constitutional and statutory requirements. The materials on record showed serious disputes about the ownership and valuation of the property, the treatment of sale proceeds, the updating of accounts, and whether the procedure for transfer of shares and alienation of assets had been followed. As the subsequent financial records were not produced and the factual position required independent verification, the Tribunal considered it appropriate to obtain expert assistance before reaching a final determination on the disputed transactions.

Conclusion: The petitioners were entitled to interim investigative relief, and an independent auditor and a practising company secretary were directed to be appointed to verify valuation, accounting, shareholding details, and statutory compliance.

Ratio Decidendi: Where the legality and financial effect of transfers of shares and company assets are seriously disputed and the record is incomplete, the Tribunal may direct independent audit and compliance verification to ascertain the true factual position before final adjudication.

---