Trust Property in Insolvency Requires Clear Dedication; mere temple book entries did not exclude the sums from the estate.

Mere book entries crediting a temple or deity did not, by themselves, establish trust property or an endowment excluded from an insolvent estate. The evidence showed no allocation of a specific fund, no separate investment, no vesting in trustees, and no clear intention to dedicate property in trust or as debutter property. The entries and surrounding conduct were instead consistent with a debtor-creditor arrangement on special terms, with interest credited in the manner of an ordinary business account. The claim to exclude the sums from the divisible estate therefore failed, and the insolvency court's earlier order in favour of the appellants was restored.

---

---

Issues: Whether the entries in the insolvent firm's books and the surrounding conduct established that the sums credited in favour of the temple were held in trust or constituted an endowment for the deity, so as to exclude them from the insolvent estate.

Analysis: The relevant insolvency provisions excluded from the divisible estate property held on trust, but the evidence showed no allocation of any specific fund, no separate investment, no vesting of property in trustees, and no intention to create a trust. The book entries were consistent with a debtor-creditor arrangement on special terms, with interest credited as in an ordinary business account, and the surrounding conduct was inconsistent with any declaration of trust or dedication of property to the deity. The alternative theory of endowment also failed because no identifiable property was shown to have been made debutter or charged in favour of the idol.

Conclusion: The claim failed to establish either a trust or an endowment, and the temple was not entitled to treat the sums as property outside the insolvent estate.

Final Conclusion: The appeal succeeded, the order restoring the Official Assignee's view was set aside, and the insolvency court's earlier order in favour of the appellants was restored.

Ratio Decidendi: Mere book entries crediting a deity or temple, without appropriation of specific property or clear intention to dedicate property in trust or as an endowment, do not create trust property excluded from the insolvent estate.

---