Amendment Notification No. 10/2004 Invalidated; Court Rules Show Cause Notice for Pre-Issuance Demands Invalid.

The SC dismissed the civil appeal, affirming the HC's decision that Amendment Notification No. 10/2004 was invalid. The notification was deemed to apply prospectively, rendering the show cause notice for demands predating its issuance invalid. The subject matter was considered tax neutral, resulting in the appeal's dismissal.

---

---

The Supreme Court dismissed the civil appeal as the Amendment Notification No. 10/2004 was held to be bad in law by the High Court. The notification would apply prospectively, and most of the demand in the case pertained to a period before its issuance, making the show cause notice invalid. The subject matter was deemed tax neutral, leading to the appeal's dismissal.

---