Pre-deposit waiver in service tax appeals: partial relief granted, recovery stayed, and limited additional deposits directed.

In pending service tax appeals involving demands confirmed under Business Support Service and Brand Promotion Service, waiver of the balance pre-deposit was granted largely because substantial amounts had already been deposited before the Commissioner (Appeals). The valuation dispute and the claim for small scale industry benefit were left for consideration at final hearing. For most appellants, recovery remained stayed pending disposal of the appeals; three appellants were nevertheless directed to make additional pre-deposits within four weeks. The operative effect was partial waiver of pre-deposit, with stay of recovery subject to limited further deposit directions.

---

---

Issues: Whether waiver of pre-deposit should be granted in the pending service tax appeals, and if so, to what extent.

Analysis: The dispute arose from service tax demands confirmed partly under Business Support Service and partly under Brand Promotion Service. The appellants had already deposited substantial amounts before the Commissioner (Appeals), and the order records that the valuation dispute and claim for small scale industry benefit would be considered at the time of final hearing. On the basis of the pre-deposits already made, waiver of the balance dues was considered appropriate for most appellants, while three appellants were directed to make additional pre-deposits within four weeks. Recovery was ordered to remain stayed pending disposal of the appeals.

Conclusion: Partial waiver of pre-deposit was granted, stay of recovery was ordered, and only specified additional deposits were required from three appellants.

---