Cenvat credit penalty waiver granted for brief excess utilisation during the fortnightly duty payment transition.

Penalties for short-term excess utilisation of Cenvat credit during the introduction of the fortnightly duty payment scheme were held fit for waiver under the Cenvat Credit and Central Excise Rules. The Tribunal noted that the excess credit was used only for a few days, duty was regularly paid in later fortnights, and any payment through PLA in the relevant fortnight would have remained available for the next period. Without deciding the underlying legality of the utilisation issue, the Tribunal concluded that the facts justified setting aside the penalties.

---

---

Issues: Whether penalties imposed for excess utilisation of Cenvat credit for a few days during the fortnightly duty payment scheme were liable to be waived.

Analysis: The only issue decided was the sustainability of the penalties under the Cenvat Credit and Central Excise Rules. The Tribunal noted that the dispute arose during the introduction of the fortnightly payment system, that the excess utilisation was only for a short period, that duty was being regularly paid in subsequent fortnights, and that even if duty had been paid through PLA in the relevant fortnight, the amount would have remained available for the next fortnight. In these circumstances, and without entering into the legality of the underlying issue, the Tribunal treated the matter as fit for waiver of penalty.

Conclusion: The penalties were set aside and the appeals were allowed in favour of the assessee.

---