2015 (10) TMI 48 - HC - VAT and Sales Tax

Exempted sales wrongly included in taxable turnover, High Court rules

HSI Automotives Ltd. Versus The State of Tamil Nadu, The Commercial Tax Officer

HSI Automotives Ltd. Versus The State of Tamil Nadu, The Commercial Tax Officer - TMI Issues Involved:1. Inclusion of exempted sales in taxable turnover for calculating the threshold limit under the Tamil Nadu Additional Sales Tax Act, 1970.2. Legality of penalty imposed under Section 12(3)(b) of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959.Issue-wise Detailed Analysis:1. Inclusion of Exempted Sales in Taxable Turnover:During the assessment year 2004-2005, the petitioner sold rubber/PVC profiles and rubber hoses to Hyundai Motors India Limited and Ford India (P) Limited, with sales to both companies being exempted under specific Government Orders. The Assessing Officer included these exempted sales in the taxable turnover to determine if the petitioner exceeded the threshold limit for the applicability of the Tamil Nadu Additional Sales Tax Act, 1970. This led to the imposition of additional sales tax and a penalty.The petitioner argued that the taxable turnover for the purposes of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959, and the Tamil Nadu Additional Sales Tax Act, 1970, should be the same. The petitioner contended that exempted sales should not be included in the taxable turnover, as it would defeat the purpose of the exemption. The Tribunal, however, upheld the inclusion of exempted sales in the taxable turnover.The High Court analyzed the historical context and amendments of the Tamil Nadu Additional Sales Tax Act, 1970, and noted that the Act did not contain a provision for definitions and relied on the definitions in the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959. The Court emphasized that the 1970 Act depended on the 1959 Act for definitions, assessment, levy, collection, and statutory remedies. It concluded that the expression 'taxable turnover' in the 1970 Act should have the same meaning as in the 1959 Act.The Court held that the Tribunal committed an error of law by including the exempted sales to Hyundai Motors in the taxable turnover for the purposes of the 1970 Act. The Court noted that the First Appellate Authority had correctly excluded the sales to Ford India based on similar exemptions under both Acts.2. Legality of Penalty Imposed:The penalty was imposed under Section 12(3)(b) of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959, based on the inclusion of exempted sales in the taxable turnover. Since the Court found that the inclusion of exempted sales was incorrect, the basis for the penalty was also invalid.The Court concluded that the levy of penalty was wrong and answered the second question of law in favor of the petitioner.Conclusion:The High Court ruled in favor of the petitioner, holding that the Tribunal erred in including exempted sales in the taxable turnover for the purposes of the Tamil Nadu Additional Sales Tax Act, 1970. Consequently, the penalty imposed was also deemed incorrect. The revision was allowed, and the Tribunal's order was set aside.