Widow's maintenance claim and estate duty were not deductible in computing the principal value of the estate.

A widow's maintenance right under Hindu law was held not to reduce the dutiable estate unless it had become an enforceable charge or encumbrance during the deceased's lifetime. Because there was no decree, agreement, or charge fastened on the property, and the widow's statutory claim was extinguished when she inherited as a Class I heir, the maintenance allowance was not deductible as a debt or encumbrance under the Estate Duty Act. Estate duty payable under the Act itself was also held not to be deductible under section 44, which is confined to debts and encumbrances created by the deceased.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether the widow's claim for maintenance allowance was deductible while computing the dutiable estate of the deceased. (ii) Whether the estate duty payable was deductible in computing the principal value of the estate.

Issue (i): Whether the widow's claim for maintenance allowance was deductible while computing the dutiable estate of the deceased.

Analysis: The widow's right to maintenance under Hindu law was a personal obligation of the husband and did not, by itself, create any charge or encumbrance on the husband's property. On the facts, there was no decree, agreement, or creation of charge fastening a definite liability on the estate during the husband's lifetime. Under the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956, the widow became a dependant on the husband's death, but her claim was not a charge on the estate unless so created, and once she inherited the entire estate as class I heir, the statutory claim stood extinguished. The deduction could not therefore be treated as a debt or encumbrance under the Estate Duty Act, 1953.

Conclusion: The deduction for maintenance allowance was not permissible and the answer was against the accountable person.

Issue (ii): Whether the estate duty payable was deductible in computing the principal value of the estate.

Analysis: Section 44 of the Estate Duty Act, 1953, was confined to debts and encumbrances created by the deceased during lifetime. Estate duty liability arose under the charging scheme of the Act itself and did not answer the description of a deductible debt or encumbrance within that provision. The earlier decision relied upon by the Court supported the view that estate duty payable by the accountable person was not an admissible deduction.

Conclusion: The estate duty payable was not deductible and the answer was against the accountable person.

Final Conclusion: Both reference questions were answered against the accountable person, leaving no deductible claim either for maintenance allowance or for estate duty in the computation of the principal value of the estate.

Ratio Decidendi: A widow's maintenance right does not reduce the dutiable estate unless it has ripened into a charge or other enforceable encumbrance before death, and estate duty payable under the Act is not a deductible debt or encumbrance under section 44.

---