Tribunal rules on commercial area restrictions & built-up area definitions for residential projects

The Tribunal ruled in favor of the assessee, holding that the restriction on commercial area and the definition of "built-up area" do not apply retrospectively to projects commenced before specific dates. The Tribunal also determined that proportionate deductions should be allowed for eligible residential units, even if some units exceed prescribed built-up area limits. The Assessing Officer was directed to re-compute the deduction for the assessee under section 80-IB(10) based on these rulings, resulting in the partial allowance of the assessee's appeals.

---

---

Issues Involved:
1. Eligibility for deduction under section 80-IB(10) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, for housing projects with commercial areas.
2. Applicability of the definition of "built-up area" for projects commenced before 1.4.2005.
3. Proportionate deduction for projects with some non-eligible residential units.

Detailed Analysis:

1. Eligibility for Deduction Under Section 80-IB(10):
The primary issue revolves around the eligibility of the assessee for deductions under section 80-IB(10) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, for two housing projects: DSK Vishwa III and DSK Frangipani. The deductions were denied by the Assessing Officer (AO) on the grounds that the projects did not meet the conditions prescribed under section 80-IB(10).

For DSK Vishwa III, the AO noted that the project included commercial areas (6132 sq.ft.), which exceeded the limits prescribed by clause (d) of section 80-IB(10). The assessee argued that the amendment introducing this restriction was effective from 1.4.2005 and should not apply retrospectively to their project, which commenced on 13.10.2000. The Tribunal upheld this view, citing the Bombay High Court's decision in CIT v Brahma Associates, which held that the amendment is prospective and not applicable to projects commenced before 1.4.2005.

For DSK Frangipani, the AO's objection was that the built-up area of some flats exceeded the 1500 sq.ft. limit prescribed in clause (c) of section 80-IB(10). The Tribunal found that the AO included balconies, terraces, and car parking areas in the built-up area calculation, which was incorrect for projects commenced before 1.4.2005. The Tribunal referred to the Development Control Rules of the local authority, which did not include these areas in the built-up area, and thus ruled in favor of the assessee.

2. Applicability of the Definition of "Built-Up Area":
The Tribunal addressed the issue of whether the definition of "built-up area," which includes balconies and terraces and was introduced by the Finance (No.2) Act, 2004, effective from 1.4.2005, applies to projects commenced before this date. The Tribunal concluded that this definition does not apply retrospectively. For projects like DSK Frangipani, which commenced on 12.12.2003, the built-up area should be calculated according to the Development Control Rules of the local authority, which exclude balconies and terraces.

3. Proportionate Deduction for Projects with Some Non-Eligible Residential Units:
The Tribunal also considered whether the presence of some non-eligible residential units (those exceeding 1500 sq.ft. in built-up area) in a project should result in the denial of the entire deduction under section 80-IB(10). The Tribunal ruled that the deduction should be proportionate, allowing for eligible units while denying it for non-eligible ones. This decision was based on precedents, including the Mumbai Bench's ruling in M/s. Ekta Housing Pvt. Ltd., which allowed for proportionate deductions in similar circumstances.

Conclusion:
The Tribunal ruled in favor of the assessee on several grounds:
- The restriction on commercial area introduced by the Finance (No.2) Act, 2004, does not apply retrospectively to projects commenced before 1.4.2005.
- The definition of "built-up area" including balconies and terraces, applicable from 1.4.2005, does not apply to projects commenced before this date.
- Proportionate deductions under section 80-IB(10) should be allowed for eligible residential units, even if some units exceed the prescribed built-up area limits.

The Tribunal directed the AO to re-compute the deduction allowable to the assessee under section 80-IB(10) based on these findings. The appeals of the assessee were partly allowed.

---