Commercial classification controls tax treatment for electronic ticketing machines; concessional rate denied where tariff entry excludes heading 8470.

A portable hand-held electronic ticketing machine was treated as a ticket-issuing machine under heading 8470, not as an information technology product under heading 8471. Classification depended on commercial identity and the tariff scheme, and the mere presence of electronic or programmable features did not bring the goods within the concessional entry. Because the notification extended only to heading 8471 and expressly did not cover ticket-issuing machines in heading 8470, the concessional 4% tax claim was not available. The classification in favour of the Revenue was upheld.

---

---

Issues: Whether a portable hand held electronic ticketing machine is an information technology product classifiable under heading 8471 so as to qualify for tax at 4%.

Analysis: The product was examined in the light of its commercial identity, the tariff entries in the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985, and the notification granting concessional tax to specified information technology products. The machine was described and marketed as a ticket issuing machine, and heading 8470 specifically covered ticket-issuing machines, while heading 8471 covered automatic data processing machines and units thereof. Since the notification adopted 8471 and did not extend to 8470, the goods could not be brought within the concessional entry merely because they contained electronic and programmable features. The classification had to follow commercial understanding rather than technical description, and the express inclusion of ticket-issuing machines under 8470 excluded the claim under 8471.

Conclusion: The machine was not classifiable under heading 8471 for concessional tax and the claim for 4% tax failed; the classification in favour of the Revenue was upheld.

---