Prior unchallenged tribunal ruling supported waiver of pre-deposit and stay of recovery in a molasses exemption dispute.

Where an earlier unchallenged Tribunal order in the assessee's own case had held that reversal of input credit attributable to inputs used in molasses manufacture removed any further duty liability on molasses and rectified spirit or neutral alcohol, that prior view could justify interim protection in a later appeal on the same exemption dispute. The Tribunal also noted that the same approach had been followed for a subsequent period and was supported by a coordinate-bench decision on similar facts. On that basis, pre-deposit was waived and recovery was stayed pending disposal of the appeal.

---

---

Issues: Whether pre-deposit should be waived and recovery stayed during the pendency of the appeal in view of an earlier final order of the Tribunal on the same issue concerning exemption on molasses cleared for captive consumption.

Analysis: The Tribunal noted that an earlier final order in the appellant's own case had held that if the input credit attributable to inputs used in the manufacture of molasses was reversed, no further duty or amount was payable on molasses or rectified spirit/neutral alcohol. That order had not been successfully challenged, the later request for rectification had been rejected, and a subsequent Commissioner had followed the same view for a later period. The Tribunal also found support in a cited coordinate-bench decision on similar facts.

Conclusion: Pre-deposit was waived and stay against recovery was granted during the pendency of the appeal.

Final Conclusion: The appellant obtained interim relief on the strength of an earlier unchallenged tribunal decision and consistent subsequent treatment of the same issue.

Ratio Decidendi: When an earlier unchallenged tribunal order on the same issue in the assessee's own case governs the dispute, interim pre-deposit relief and stay may be granted pending appeal.

---