Scrap classification of imported steel strips turns on technical verification of reuse, not declarations alone

Classification of imported silicon electrical steel strips depended on whether the goods were truly waste and scrap or old and used articles capable of reuse. The applicable tariff and HSN notes treat metal goods as scrap only when they are definitely not usable as such because of breakage, cutting up, wear or similar reasons; reusable goods are excluded. The record contained conflicting indicators, but the physical and technical characteristics were not properly verified because no representative sample was examined by an expert or dealer in such goods. The finding that the goods were not scrap was therefore unsustainable on the existing record, and fresh adjudication was directed after technical examination of representative samples in the importer's presence.

---

---

Issues: Whether the imported goods were scrap freely importable or old and used silicon electrical steel strips whose import was restricted, and whether the matter required fresh adjudication on proper technical examination.

Analysis: Classification under the tariff and the HSN explanatory notes turns on the legal text and the actual nature of the goods. Waste and scrap covers metal goods definitely not usable as such because of breakage, cutting up, wear or similar reasons, while articles capable of reuse for their former or other purposes are excluded. The record showed conflicting indicators: the dock report described the goods as appearing to be scrap, whereas the adjudicating authority relied mainly on the importer's declaration and the absence of proof of intended remelting. No representative sample was examined by an expert or by a person dealing in such goods, and the physical and technical characteristics of the goods were not adequately verified.

Conclusion: The finding that the goods were not scrap could not be sustained on the existing record, and the matter was remanded for fresh adjudication after technical examination of representative samples in the presence of the importer's representative.

---