Tribunal decision on software expenses & disallowance under section 14A for assessment years 2007-08 & 2008-09

The Tribunal partly allowed the Assessee's appeal for assessment year 2007-08, directing the AO to treat certain software expenses as revenue expenditure. It upheld the CIT(A)'s disallowance under section 14A for assessment year 2007-08 at Rs. 86,805. For assessment year 2008-09, the Tribunal modified the CIT(A)'s disallowance under section 14A to Rs. 3,50,000. The Assessee's appeal for assessment year 2008-09 was dismissed, and the Revenue's appeal was partly allowed.

---

---

Issues Involved:
1. Disallowance of software expense for assessment year 2007-08.
2. Disallowance made under section 14A of the Income Tax Act for assessment year 2007-08.
3. Disallowance made under section 14A of the Income Tax Act for assessment year 2008-09.

Detailed Analysis:

1. Disallowance of Software Expense for Assessment Year 2007-08:
The Assessee, an asset manager of a mutual fund, claimed software expenses as revenue expenditure. The Assessing Officer (AO) treated these expenses as capital expenditure, allowing depreciation at 60% as per the Depreciation Schedule. The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) [CIT(A)] upheld this decision for most software except for "Capitaline," which was an annual payment and thus allowed as revenue expenditure.

The Tribunal, however, referenced the Delhi High Court's decision in CIT Vs. Indian Visit.Com (P) Ltd, which categorized website development charges as revenue expenditure. It also cited the Punjab & Haryana High Court's ruling in CIT Vs. Varinder Agro Chemicals Ltd, emphasizing that software expenses are revenue in nature if they are not of enduring benefit and become outdated quickly. The Tribunal concluded that software like "Wealth spectrum," "i-deal," and "Chart FX" are functional and supportive, thus qualifying as revenue expenditure. However, "Windows Server, 2003" and "Adobe Photoshop" were deemed capital expenditures due to their longer utility life.

2. Disallowance Made Under Section 14A for Assessment Year 2007-08:
The AO disallowed Rs. 25,26,129 under section 14A, applying Rule 8D, which mandates disallowance of administrative expenses related to exempt income. The Assessee argued that no expenses were incurred for earning the exempt income and cited the Bombay High Court's decision in Godrej & Boyce Mfg Co Ltd Vs DCIT, which held Rule 8D applicable prospectively from assessment year 2008-09.

The CIT(A) accepted the Assessee's revised disallowance of Rs. 86,805 based on a reasonable basis, considering the limited number of transactions and the direct credit of dividends to the bank account. The Tribunal upheld this disallowance, noting that the Assessee itself had provided a working of the disallowance at Rs. 86,805, which included a portion of salary and minor conveyance and communication expenses.

3. Disallowance Made Under Section 14A for Assessment Year 2008-09:
For assessment year 2008-09, the AO applied Rule 8D, resulting in a disallowance of Rs. 1,46,78,090. The Assessee had initially disallowed Rs. 1,25,605 in its return. The CIT(A) reduced the disallowance to Rs. 1,25,66,793, accepting that only investments yielding income should be considered under Rule 8D(2)(iii).

The Tribunal noted that the Assessee's investments were primarily in its own mutual fund schemes and group concerns, which do not require complex analysis. It also observed that the Assessee's transactions were limited, with most dividends received through direct credit or reinvestment. The Tribunal found the Assessee's initial disallowance too low and the AO's application of Rule 8D excessive. It determined a fair disallowance of Rs. 3,50,000, modifying the CIT(A)'s order accordingly.

Conclusion:
The Tribunal partly allowed the Assessee's appeal for assessment year 2007-08, directing the AO to treat certain software expenses as revenue expenditure. It upheld the CIT(A)'s disallowance under section 14A for assessment year 2007-08 at Rs. 86,805. For assessment year 2008-09, the Tribunal modified the CIT(A)'s disallowance under section 14A to Rs. 3,50,000. The Assessee's appeal for assessment year 2008-09 was dismissed, and the Revenue's appeal was partly allowed.

---