Statutory authority limits on tax clarifications: a non-binding clarification cannot fetter independent assessment under the VAT law.

A tax clarification issued without statutory authority cannot bind the assessing authority or override the TNVAT Act. The Madras High Court held that the Tamil Nadu Value Added Tax Act, 2006 contained no enabling provision empowering the officer to issue binding circulars or clarifications beyond the statutory scheme, and that a superior tax officer's clarification cannot add to, subtract from, or control the quasi-judicial discretion of the assessing officer. Section 48A, introduced later, did not confer any independent power to sustain the impugned clarification. The clarification was therefore without authority, and the petitioner's objections had to be considered independently in accordance with the Act.

---

---

Issues: Whether the Commissioner had authority under the Tamil Nadu Value Added Tax Act to issue the impugned clarification and whether the clarification could bind the assessing authority.

Analysis: The definition of capital goods under section 2(11) of the Tamil Nadu Value Added Tax Act, 2006 was discussed only to show the nature of the dispute, but the decisive question was the source of power to issue a binding clarification. The Court held that, unlike the repealed TNGST regime, the TNVAT Act contained no enabling provision authorising the first respondent to issue circulars or clarifications on matters beyond the statutory scheme. It was further held that even a clarification issued by a superior tax officer cannot override the Act, cannot control the quasi-judicial discretion of the assessing authority, and cannot add to or subtract from the statutory provisions. The Court also noted that section 48A, introduced later, did not support any independent power in the first respondent to issue the impugned clarification.

Conclusion: The impugned clarification was without authority and could not bind the assessing officer; the writ petition was allowed and the petitioner was entitled to have its objections considered independently in accordance with the Act.

Ratio Decidendi: A tax circular or clarification issued without statutory authority is non est and cannot override the provisions of the taxing statute or fetter the independent decision-making power of the assessing authority.

---