Overriding statutory charge on co-operative society receipts makes education fund contribution deductible, not taxable income.

A compulsory contribution by a co-operative society to the Co-operative Education Fund, imposed under the Karnataka Co-operative Societies law when dividend is declared, was treated as an overriding charge on receipts rather than an appropriation of profits. Because the liability arose by reference to profits before income finally accrued to the society, the amount was held to be diverted at source and not part of taxable income. The contribution was therefore deductible in computing income, and the issue was decided in favour of the assessee and against the Revenue.

---

---

Issues: Whether the contribution paid by a co-operative society to the Co-operative Education Fund under the Karnataka Co-operative Societies law was deductible in computing taxable income, or whether it was merely an application of profits.

Analysis: The contribution was statutorily compelled when the society declared dividend at the prescribed rate and the liability arose by reference to profits, not as an appropriation out of profits after they accrued. The scheme of the Act and Rules showed that the payment operated as an overriding charge on the receipts of the society, so that the amount was diverted at source before it could become income in the hands of the assessee. The payment therefore fell on the side of diversion of income at source rather than application of income. The Court distinguished authorities dealing with statutory appropriations from profits and preferred the line of reasoning treating a compulsory fund contribution as a pre-income charge.

Conclusion: The contribution to the Co-operative Education Fund was deductible and the issue was answered in favour of the assessee and against the Revenue.

Final Conclusion: A compulsory statutory contribution computed with reference to profits, but imposed as an overriding charge on receipts, is not taxable income in the hands of the assessee.

Ratio Decidendi: Where a statute fastens a mandatory payment on the receipts of a society as an overriding charge before profits are finally ascertained, the amount is diverted at source and is deductible in computing taxable income.

---