Specific classification of vehicle belts prevails over general rubber products entry for tax purposes.

Fan belts and tractor belts sold as automobile spare parts were classified under the specific entries for motor vehicles, two wheelers and tractors, together with their parts and accessories, rather than under the general entry for rubber products. The court applied the principle that a specific classification prevails over a general one, and held that belts marketed for use in vehicles did not fall within the rubber-products entry for conveyor, transmission or elevator belts. Their use and commercial identity aligned them with vehicle parts, so the assessees were taxable under the specific vehicle-related entries.

---

---

Issues: Whether fan belts and tractor belts sold as automobile spare parts were classifiable under the specific entries relating to vehicles and their parts and accessories, or under the general entry relating to rubber products.

Analysis: The Schedule contained specific entries for motor vehicles, two wheelers and tractors, together with their parts and accessories, both before and after the amendment. Entry 50, by contrast, was a general entry dealing with rubber products, including conveyor, transmission or elevator belts or belting of rubber. On a combined reading of the entries, the belts sold for use in automobiles, two wheelers and tractors were not conveyor or transmission belts in the sense contemplated by the rubber products entry. The goods took colour from their particular use and from the specific vehicle-related entries, and the assessee was a dealer in automobile parts rather than in general rubber products.

Conclusion: The belts were taxable under the specific entries for vehicle parts and accessories and not under the general entry for rubber products. The revisions were therefore liable to fail.

Ratio Decidendi: Where a statute contains a specific entry covering goods by reference to their use as vehicle parts or accessories, that specific classification prevails over a general entry for rubber products when the goods are not of the general class described in the latter entry.

---