Valuation of unquoted shares requires excluding advance tax and deducting only the real taxation liability under rule 1D.

While valuing unquoted equity shares under rule 1D of the Wealth-tax Rules, advance tax already paid must be excluded from assets, and only the provision for taxation representing the actual tax payable for the year may be treated as a liability. Any excess provision beyond the tax payable does not reflect a real liability and must be ignored. The Court rejected the contention that the entire provision for taxation could be deducted, holding that the tax burden is recognised only once through the combined treatment of advance tax and the proper balance of provision.

---

---

Issues: Whether, while valuing unquoted equity shares under rule 1D of the Wealth-tax Rules, 1957, the entire provision for taxation shown in the company's balance-sheet must be deducted as a liability, or only the amount of provision necessary after excluding advance tax already paid.

Analysis: Rule 1D, read with Explanation II, requires the break-up value of unquoted shares to be computed by excluding advance tax already paid from the assets side and by treating as a liability only the amount of provision for taxation that corresponds to the tax actually payable for the relevant year. Any excess over the tax payable does not represent a real liability and must be disregarded. The total tax burden for the year is therefore allowed only once, partly through exclusion of advance tax from assets and partly through deduction of the proper balance as provision for taxation. The Court rejected the view that the entire provision for taxation could be deducted irrespective of the tax already paid.

Conclusion: The assessee's contention was rejected, and only the excess provision beyond the tax payable after giving credit for advance tax is to be ignored in computing the share value.

---