Section 4A valuation turns on whether pesticide packs are retail packages; 25 kg packs required fresh factual examination.

Section 4A of the Central Excise Act applies only where goods are required to bear MRP under the Standards of Weights and Measures law. On the facts stated, 25 kg pesticide and insecticide packages cleared to a registered dealer were asserted to be non-retail packs later converted into 5 kg retail packs, with duty paid on the MRP basis at that stage. Because that factual claim had not been examined or rejected, and the materials did not show that the 25 kg packs themselves entered retail sale or were meant for ultimate consumers, they could not then be treated as retail packages for Section 4A. The impugned order was set aside and the matter remanded for fresh factual examination.

---

---

Issues: Whether 25 kg packages of pesticides and insecticides cleared to a registered dealer were retail packages liable to assessment under Section 4A of the Central Excise Act, 1944, or were non-retail packages assessable otherwise.

Analysis: Section 4A applies only to packages which are required to bear maximum retail price under the Standards of Weights and Measures law. The appellant asserted that the 25 kg packages were not meant for sale as retail packs, but were further received by the dealer and converted into 5 kg retail packs on which duty was discharged on the MRP basis. That factual plea had not been examined or rejected by the adjudicating authority. On the materials then available, the Revenue had not shown that the 25 kg packages themselves entered retail sale or were meant for consumption by the ultimate consumer.

Conclusion: The 25 kg packages could not, at that stage, be treated as retail packages attracting Section 4A, and the appellant was held to have a prima facie case for relief. The impugned order was set aside and the matter was remanded for fresh examination of the factual claim.

---