Strict compliance with net foreign exchange earnings conditions governs DTA exemption for export-oriented undertakings.

An exemption for DTA clearances by a 100% export-oriented undertaking under Notification No. 13/98 was available only on strict compliance with the notification and Export and Import Policy conditions. The exemption was conditional on the goods being permitted for sale in India and on fulfilment of the prescribed net foreign exchange earnings requirement under paragraph 9.9(b). As the record showed that the unit had failed to achieve positive net foreign exchange earnings, the mandatory condition was not met and the exemption claim for the disputed period failed. The demand was therefore sustained, and the appellant did not succeed.

---

---

Issues: Whether the appellant was entitled to exemption under Notification No. 13/98 for DTA clearances despite failure to achieve the prescribed net foreign exchange earnings.

Analysis: The notification granted exemption to goods manufactured in a 100% export-oriented undertaking from indigenous raw materials, but only if the goods were permitted for sale in India in accordance with the relevant Export and Import Policy conditions. Paragraph 9.9(b) made DTA sale contingent upon fulfilment of the minimum net foreign exchange earnings requirement. The record also showed that the Development Commissioner had found that the unit failed to achieve positive net foreign exchange earnings. Exemption notifications are to be strictly construed, and the appellant did not establish compliance with the mandatory condition. The cited precedents were found distinguishable on their facts.

Conclusion: The appellant was not entitled to the exemption for the disputed period and the claim failed.

Final Conclusion: The demand was sustained and the appeal did not succeed.

Ratio Decidendi: An exemption for DTA clearances by a 100% export-oriented undertaking is available only on strict compliance with the notification and policy conditions, including achievement of the prescribed net foreign exchange earnings where such compliance is made mandatory.

---