Refractory items not eligible for energy-device exemption where kiln or furnace was not shown to be machinery producing energy.

Exemption under Notification No. 3/2001-C.E. was unavailable because the refractory items were not shown to be parts of a kiln or furnace qualifying as a device for producing energy. The claimed characterisation of the kiln or furnace as an industrial conversion device was found untenable, and the appellant was engaged in manufacturing refractory materials rather than any machine, machinery, or non-conventional energy device. On those facts, the goods could not be treated as parts of machinery producing energy, so the exemption claim failed.

---

---

Issues: Whether the appellant was entitled to exemption under Notification No. 3/2001-C.E. dated 1-3-2001 for the impugned refractory items on the footing that they were parts of a kiln or furnace treated as a device for producing energy.

Analysis: The claimed characterisation of the kiln or furnace as an industrial conversion device producing energy was found untenable. The appellant was engaged in the manufacture of refractory materials and not in the manufacture of any machine, machinery, or non-conventional energy device. On the facts, the impugned goods could not be treated as parts of any machinery producing energy, and the exemption claim remained unsubstantiated.

Conclusion: The exemption was rightly denied and the appeal failed.

---