MODVAT credit for duty-paid inputs in stock was admissible when a final product became dutiable; penalties were set aside.

MODVAT credit under Rule 57H was considered admissible for duty-paid inputs lying in stock when the final product first became dutiable, including inputs contained in semi-finished or finished goods. The controlling test was whether the inputs were duty paid and available in stock on the relevant date, either as such or embedded in the product, and documentary proof of duty payment was sufficient. The Tribunal rejected the additional requirement that the inputs be shown in tangible physical form and held that the authority could not deny credit by adding a condition not found in the remand directions or by applying a first-come first-out approach. The penalties were set aside.

---

---

Issues: Whether MODVAT credit under Rule 57H of the Central Excise Rules, 1944 was admissible in respect of duty-paid inputs lying in stock or contained in semi-finished or finished goods on the date the final product became dutiable, and whether the penalties could survive.

Analysis: The credit claim arose from a transition when the final product, earlier exempt, became dutiable, and the assessee sought credit for inputs available in stock in whatever form on the relevant date. The adjudicating authority introduced an additional requirement that the inputs must be shown to exist in tangible physical form, but the Tribunal held that this was not a part of the remand directions. The controlling considerations were whether the inputs were duty paid and whether they were available in stock on the relevant date, either as such or embedded in the final product. On those facts, the documentary evidence of duty payment was sufficient, and the authority could not deny credit by applying a first-come first-out approach or by adding a further condition not warranted by the remand.

Conclusion: MODVAT credit under Rule 57H was held admissible, and the penalties were set aside.

---