Taxable value in warranty service: spare parts may be treated separately from service charges for interim protection.

For pre-deposit and interim stay in a service tax dispute, spare parts used during free warranty servicing were considered potentially separable from the taxable value of the service. The Tribunal noted that labour charges were billed separately and that spare parts replaced in warranty work were reimbursed by the manufacturer, with supporting decisions indicating such goods may not form part of taxable service value. As the applicant's claim that billing was routed through debit notes had not been adequately examined, and a distinct value for goods used in the service was arguable, interim protection was granted and recovery of the confirmed dues was stayed pending appeal.

---

---

Issues: Whether, for purposes of pre-deposit and interim stay in a service tax dispute, the value of spare parts used in free warranty service could be treated as part of the taxable value of the service.

Analysis: The dispute concerned authorised warranty servicing of motor vehicles, where labour charges were billed separately and spare parts replaced during warranty service were reimbursed by the manufacturer. The Tribunal noted that there were decisions supporting the view that spare parts used in such warranty service do not form part of the value of taxable service, and that the applicant's assertion regarding billing through debit notes had not been properly considered at the adjudication stage. The existence of a possible separable value for goods used in the course of service justified interim protection.

Conclusion: Waiver of pre-deposit was granted and recovery of the confirmed dues was stayed during pendency of the appeal.

---