Recognition certificate sales and statutory exemption issues required fresh consideration under the Trade Tax Act notification framework.

Clause (3) of the 29 August 1987 notification continued to apply to sales of oil seeds to a dealer holding a recognition certificate against Form 3-B, so the reduced 2% rate could not be denied merely because earlier notifications under Section 4-B had been superseded. Separately, exemption claimed on sales against Form 3-C(1) arose under Section 3-D(7) of the Trade Tax Act and was not displaced by that notification. The Tribunal had failed to examine both claims on the correct legal basis, so its order was found unsustainable and the matter was restored for fresh consideration.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether sales of oil seeds made to a dealer holding a recognition certificate against Form 3-B were liable to tax at the reduced rate of 2% under clause (3) of the notification dated 29 August 1987 despite supersession of earlier notifications under Section 4-B of the Trade Tax Act; (ii) Whether exemption from tax on sales made against Form 3-C(1) was governed by Section 3-D(7) of the Trade Tax Act and unaffected by the said notification.

Issue (i): Whether sales of oil seeds made to a dealer holding a recognition certificate against Form 3-B were liable to tax at the reduced rate of 2% under clause (3) of the notification dated 29 August 1987 despite supersession of earlier notifications under Section 4-B of the Trade Tax Act.

Analysis: Clause (3) of the notification dated 29 August 1987 specifically provided that sales to, or purchases by, a dealer holding a recognition certificate of goods covered by the relevant annexure and used as raw material for manufacture of notified goods would attract tax at 2%. The earlier notifications having been superseded did not exclude the operation of this clause. The Tribunal had overlooked this part of the notification while denying the reduced rate.

Conclusion: The assessee's claim to the reduced rate of tax on Form 3-B sales required reconsideration under clause (3) of the notification dated 29 August 1987.

Issue (ii): Whether exemption from tax on sales made against Form 3-C(1) was governed by Section 3-D(7) of the Trade Tax Act and unaffected by the said notification.

Analysis: The exemption claimed on Form 3-C(1) sales arose under Section 3-D(7) of the Trade Tax Act. The notification dated 29 August 1987 had no application to dilute or displace that statutory exemption. The Tribunal failed to examine the claim on that footing.

Conclusion: The exemption claim under Section 3-D(7) also had to be examined afresh.

Final Conclusion: The Tribunal's order was unsustainable and was set aside, with the matter restored for fresh adjudication of the assessee's claims.

---