Tribunal grants 100% waiver for Cenvat Credit dispute

The Tribunal granted a 100% waiver of the pre-deposit requirement for the Applicants in a case involving the denial of Cenvat Credit due to a differential value in commercial invoice and Bills of Entry. The duty had been paid by the Bellary Unit, but credit had not been claimed initially. After verifying the facts, the Tribunal concluded that the Applicants were entitled to credit based on the duty paid documents of the Bills of Entry. Consequently, the Tribunal waived the pre-deposit of the entire duty, interest, and penalty during the appeal's pendency in favor of the Applicants.

---

---

Issues:
Seeking waiver of pre-deposit of Cenvat Credit due to differential value in commercial invoice and Bills of Entry.

Analysis:
The Applicants sought waiver of pre-deposit amounting to Rs.11,19,681 due to the denial of Cenvat Credit based on the differential value between the commercial invoice and the Bills of Entry. The case involved the import of M.S scrap to the Applicant's unit in Bellary, with subsequent transfer to the Salem unit. The Applicant claimed Cenvat credit based on the CVD paid, endorsed in the Bills of Entry. However, a Show Cause Notice challenged this credit claiming discrepancy in the value of goods between the commercial invoice and Bills of Entry. The differential duty element was denied, leading to a confirmed demand.

Upon hearing both parties and examining the records, it was established that the duty had been paid by the Bellary Unit, but credit had not been claimed. The adjudicating authority verified this fact, concluding that the Applicants were indeed entitled to credit based on the duty paid documents of the Bills of Entry. Consequently, the Tribunal found merit in the Applicant's case for a 100% waiver of the pre-deposit requirement. Thus, the Tribunal waived the pre-deposit of the entire duty, interest, and penalty during the appeal's pendency, in favor of the Applicants.

---