Construction service classification for telecom towers: incidental site work could not be taxed separately, securing waiver of pre-deposit.

The dispute concerned whether activities connected with construction of telecommunication towers, including site clearing, de-watering, sand filling in plinth and waste disposal, could be segregated and classified as site formation and allied services for service tax and penalty purposes, or treated as part of construction service for abatement under the exemption notifications. The Tribunal found those activities to be incidental and ancillary to the main construction contract, and held that the separate taxable classification was not sustainable even at the prima facie stage. On that basis, the appellants were granted waiver of pre-deposit and unconditional stay; limitation was not examined.

---

---

Issues: Whether the appellants had made out a prima facie case for waiver of pre-deposit in respect of the demand of service tax and penalty arising from the classification of the work as site formation and allied services instead of construction service, and the consequent claim of abatement under the relevant exemption notifications.

Analysis: The contract was primarily for construction of telecommunication towers. Activities such as clearing the site, de-watering, filling sand in plinth and disposal of waste material were found to be incidental and ancillary to the main construction activity. On that basis, the attempt to segregate those activities and treat them as a separate taxable category was held to be unsustainable at the prima facie stage. Since the appellants had a strong case on merits, the Tribunal did not examine limitation.

Conclusion: The appellants were entitled to waiver of pre-deposit and unconditional stay.

---