1991 (6) TMI 8 - HC - Income Tax

Court denies capital gains deduction for charitable trust under Income-tax Act, emphasizing real income criteria.

Director Of Income-Tax (Exemption) Versus Girdharilal Shewnarain Tantia Trust

Director Of Income-Tax (Exemption) Versus Girdharilal Shewnarain Tantia Trust - [1993] 199 ITR 215, 71 TAXMANN 150 Issues Involved:1. Eligibility of capital gains for deduction u/s 80T.2. Interpretation of 'income' u/s 11 of the Income-tax Act, 1961.3. Applicability of statutory deductions under different heads of income for a charitable trust.Summary:1. Eligibility of Capital Gains for Deduction u/s 80T:The Tribunal had held that the capital gain amounting to Rs. 2,91,644 on the sale of shares by the assessee-trust was eligible for deduction u/s 80T of the Income-tax Act, 1961. However, the High Court disagreed, stating that the income from property held for charitable or religious purposes, including capital gains, must be treated separately and the conditions specified in section 11 must be fulfilled for exemption from taxation. The court concluded that the question of deduction u/s 80T does not arise when the trust loses the benefit of accumulation.2. Interpretation of 'Income' u/s 11 of the Income-tax Act, 1961:The court emphasized that the 'income' referred to in section 11 is the real income and not the income as assessed or assessable. The income should be understood in its commercial sense, i.e., book income, after adding back any appropriations or applications towards the purposes of the trust. The court referred to the Division Bench decision in CIT v. Jayashree Charity Trust [1986] 159 ITR 280, which held that the income must be the real income actually received by the trust and not the notional income.3. Applicability of Statutory Deductions under Different Heads of Income for a Charitable Trust:The court clarified that when a part of the income of a trust becomes taxable due to non-compliance with section 11(2), the entire income accumulated becomes liable to assessment u/s 11(3). The court noted that the head of income is irrelevant unless the entire income comes from one specific head. The statutory deductions under different heads of income do not apply when the trust loses the benefit of accumulation. The court also referred to the circular of the Central Board of Direct Taxes dated June 19, 1968, which stated that the word 'income' in section 11(1)(a) must be understood in a commercial sense.Conclusion:The High Court answered the reference question in the negative and in favor of the Revenue, holding that the capital gain amounting to Rs. 2,91,644 is not eligible for deduction u/s 80T of the Income-tax Act, 1961. There was no order as to costs.