Edible oil classification for bakery margarine allowed concessional tax treatment under the Kerala sales tax schedule.

Bakery margarine was treated as edible oil for the Kerala General Sales Tax Act because the product is made from vegetable and hydrogenated oils, serves as a butter substitute, and is used in bakery and confectionery items for human consumption. The Court also relied on the Government circular, which read the reduced-rate category of edible oil broadly and treated refined or hydrogenated oils as illustrative rather than exhaustive. On that basis, margarine was not excluded merely because it is mainly used in bakery products, and it qualified for the concessional tax rate of 4%.

---

---

Issues: Whether bakery margarine is edible oil so as to fall under Entry 17A of the Second Schedule to the Kerala General Sales Tax Act, 1963 and qualify for the reduced rate of tax of 4%.

Analysis: Entry 90 of the First Schedule taxed oils, edible or inedible, including refined or hydrogenated oils and margarine, at 8%, while Entry 17A of the Second Schedule granted a reduced rate to edible oil. The Court noted that margarine is a substitute for butter, is manufactured from vegetable and hydrogenated oils, and is used in making bakery and confectionary products for human consumption. The Government circular clarifying the reduced-rate notification treated edible oil inclusively, stating that refined or hydrogenated oils such as groundnut oil, gingelly oil, refined oil and vanaspathi were covered; the list was illustrative and not exhaustive. On that basis, margarine could not be excluded merely because it was used mainly in bakery products and not in ordinary cooking.

Conclusion: Bakery margarine is edible oil and is entitled to the concessional rate of tax of 4% under Entry 17A.

---