Metal scrap from repair work is excisable when generated through mechanical working of materials for machinery replacement.

Metal waste and scrap generated during cutting and working of plates, angles, channels and similar materials for repair and maintenance of plant and machinery was treated as excisable when it arose from the mechanical working of metals in the course of making or replacing parts. Section Note 8(a) to Section XV of the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985 was applied to cover scrap produced through manufacture or mechanical working, including where material is rendered unusable by cutting, wear and tear, or similar causes. The earlier objection was rejected, and the scrap was held dutiable; the penalty was also sustained.

---

---

Issues: Whether waste and scrap generated during cutting of metal plates, angles, channels and similar materials for repair and maintenance of plant and machinery is exigible to central excise duty, and whether penalty was sustainable.

Analysis: The waste and scrap arose when metal materials were cut and worked for making and replacing parts of plant and machinery during repairs and maintenance. Under Section Note 8(a) to Section XV of the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985, metal waste and scrap generated from manufacture or mechanical working of metals, including those rendered unusable because of breakage, cutting up, wear and tear or other reasons, is covered by the tariff entry. The earlier view relied on by the appellants was not accepted, as the controlling reasoning was that the scrap came into existence in the course of manufacturing the replacement parts and the Rajasthan High Court had already treated such scrap as arising from manufacture within the statutory meaning.

Conclusion: The scrap was dutiable and the demand was sustainable. The penalty was also justified.

Final Conclusion: The appeals were rejected after holding that metal scrap generated in the course of repair and maintenance work falls within the excisable category and that the assessee's conduct warranted penalty.

Ratio Decidendi: Metal waste and scrap generated during the mechanical working of metal in the course of making or replacing plant and machinery parts is excisable under the tariff entry covering waste and scrap arising from manufacture or mechanical working of metals.

---