Airport service tax hinges on whether receipts are service consideration or mere rent, licence fee, or space occupation charges.

Under airport services, only receipts that are truly consideration for services rendered at the airport are taxable; amounts in substance representing lease rent, licence fee or space occupation charges fall outside the levy. Royalty and licence fee receipts for various airport facilities, and entry ticket and commercial pass charges, were treated as non-taxable because they were connected with allotment or restriction of space rather than service provision. By contrast, guest room charges, courtesy coach parking and surcharge on prepaid taxi were treated as taxable airport service receipts. The matter was remitted for fresh quantification of tax, interest and penalty on that basis.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether royalty and licence fee collected for ground handling, foreign exchange counters, duty free sales, advertising, cargo space, car park, shops, restaurant, telephone booths, vending machines, catering and facilitation counters were taxable as airport services; (ii) Whether income from guest room charges, courtesy coach parking and surcharge on prepaid taxi was taxable as airport services; (iii) Whether entry ticket charges and commercial pass charges were liable to service tax.

Issue (i): Whether royalty and licence fee collected for ground handling, foreign exchange counters, duty free sales, advertising, cargo space, car park, shops, restaurant, telephone booths, vending machines, catering and facilitation counters were taxable as airport services.

Analysis: The relevant taxable service covered services provided by an airport authority or a person authorized by it in an airport or civil enclave. On the facts, the amounts received from Air India, Thomas Cook, BPCL and Atlas Jewellery, and the various licence fees, were found to represent consideration for lease, rent, or allotment of space and not consideration for services rendered by the appellant. The agreements showed that the space was let out for specified purposes and that in the case of ground handling, the actual service provider had already discharged service tax on the gross receipts. The Board's circular on airport charges was relied on only to the extent that letting out premises is not itself a taxable service.

Conclusion: These receipts were held not liable to service tax and the finding was in favour of the assessee.

Issue (ii): Whether income from guest room charges, courtesy coach parking and surcharge on prepaid taxi was taxable as airport services.

Analysis: Guest room charges were treated as charges for accommodation provided to passengers and therefore as part of airport services. Courtesy coach parking was treated as a facility extended in the airport, and surcharge on prepaid taxi was also treated as connected with services rendered at the airport. These receipts were distinguished from mere rent or licence fee.

Conclusion: These receipts were held taxable and the finding was against the assessee.

Issue (iii): Whether entry ticket charges and commercial pass charges were liable to service tax.

Analysis: These amounts were collected for restricting public access to certain areas of the airport and were not found to be consideration for any service rendered by the appellant. The receipts were therefore not treated as taxable airport service income.

Conclusion: These receipts were held not liable to service tax and the finding was in favour of the assessee.

Final Conclusion: The demand was sustained only to the extent of taxable receipts identified by the Tribunal, while the remaining receipts were excluded from the levy. The matter was sent back for fresh quantification of tax, interest and penalty on the basis of the Tribunal's findings.

Ratio Decidendi: For service tax under airport services, only amounts that are truly consideration for services rendered at the airport are taxable; receipts that are in substance lease rent, licence fee or space occupation charges are outside the levy.

---