Classification of assembled mobile telescopic tower must precede valuation and excise duty assessment on the complete unit.

Duty on a mobile telescopic tower mounted on a chassis/trailer had to be examined on the basis of the product as cleared in assembled form, not as the tower alone. The proper classification of the complete unit was a necessary first step before fixing valuation, excise duty liability, or any exemption benefit. The original authority's approach of assessing only the tower was found unsustainable on the record, because the assembled vehicle was the relevant excisable product. The matter was remanded for fresh consideration of classification, valuation, duty liability, and notification benefit after hearing the assessee.

---

---

Issues: Whether the final product cleared as a mobile telescopic tower mounted on chassis/trailers was required to be reclassified before determining valuation and excise duty liability, and whether the original order confirming demand on a different valuation basis could stand.

Analysis: The product was cleared in an assembled form, namely the mobile telescopic tower mounted on the chassis/trailer, and not as a separate tower and chassis for taxation purposes. Since the duty liability depended on the proper categorisation of the final product as cleared from the unit, the classification issue had to be examined first and in the correct perspective. The original authority had proceeded on the footing that the tower alone could be considered for classification, while the record showed that the whole assembled vehicle was relevant for valuation and duty determination. The Tribunal held that this approach was not legally sustainable and that the question of proper classification, valuation, and any applicable exemption had to be re-examined.

Conclusion: The original order was set aside and the matter was remanded for fresh examination of classification, valuation, duty liability, and applicable notification benefit after giving the appellant an opportunity of hearing.

---