Systematic racing and betting activity can be assessable income, allowing related losses as set-off under the income-tax law.

Where racing stable operations and repeated betting transactions are carried on systematically with a profit-making object, the receipts may fall within business, vocation or occupation, rather than being treated as casual and non-recurring. The majority held that, on the facts, the assessee's horse-racing and betting activity was assessable income and not shown to fall within the exempt class. As the receipts were brought within a chargeable head under the Act, the related racing and betting losses were allowable by way of set-off under Section 24(1).

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether the assessee's maintenance of a racing stable and series of betting transactions constituted business, vocation, occupation, or other assessable source under the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922; (ii) whether the losses incurred in racing and betting were deductible by way of set-off under Section 24(1).

Issue (i): Whether the assessee's maintenance of a racing stable and series of betting transactions constituted business, vocation, occupation, or other assessable source under the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922.

Analysis: The charge to income-tax under Sections 4 and 6 of the Act extends to income, profits, and gains from all sources not excluded by Section 4(3). The majority held that, on the facts disclosed, the assessee's horse-racing activity and betting were carried on systematically and with a profit-making object, so that they could fall within business or at least within vocation or occupation and were not shown to be merely casual and non-recurring receipts. The dissenting view treated the activities as a hobby or pastime and not a commercial undertaking on the meagre facts proved.

Conclusion: The majority held in favour of the assessee on this issue.

Issue (ii): Whether the losses incurred in racing and betting were deductible by way of set-off under Section 24(1).

Analysis: A set-off is available only where the loss is under a head mentioned in Section 6. The majority concluded that the assessee had brought the racing and betting receipts within assessable heads and had not been shown to fall within the exempt class in Section 4(3)(vii), so the burden on the department was not discharged. The dissent held that the receipts were not shown to be assessable income and therefore no set-off was available.

Conclusion: The majority held that the assessee was entitled to deduct both the racing loss and the betting loss.

Final Conclusion: By majority, the reference was answered in favour of the assessee on both questions, with the result that the claimed losses were held allowable as set-off against assessable income.

Ratio Decidendi: Where racing or betting is carried on systematically with a profit-making object, the question whether the resulting receipts are assessable income depends on the facts of the case, and such receipts are not excluded merely because gambling or sport is involved; losses from such activities are deductible if they arise under a head of income chargeable under the Act.

---