Factory leasing without financial lease features is not taxable as banking and other financial services.

Leasing of an entire factory, together with plant, machinery and other assets, by a manufacturing unit was not treated as taxable banking and other financial services where the arrangement was a fixed-term rental lease, with no transfer of ownership, no right for the lessee to acquire the assets, and no other features of financial leasing. The Tribunal noted that the service entry covers financial leasing, equipment leasing and hire-purchase, but mere leasing of factory premises and machinery by a non-lease-finance business does not satisfy those attributes. On that basis, the tax demand was held unsustainable and the Revenue's appeals were rejected.

---

---

Issues: Whether leasing of an entire factory, together with plant, machinery and other assets, by sugar manufacturing units amounted to taxable "banking and other financial services" under the Finance Act, 1994.

Analysis: The taxable entry covered services provided by a banking company, financial institution, non-banking financial company, body corporate or commercial concern in relation to banking and other financial services, including financial leasing services such as equipment leasing and hire-purchase. The arrangement in question was not a financing transaction: the factory was leased for a fixed term on a rental basis, there was no transfer of ownership at the end of the term, no indication that the lessee would acquire the assets, and the incidents of financial leasing were absent. The Tribunal relied on earlier decisions holding that mere leasing of factory premises and machinery by a manufacturing unit, which is not engaged in lease finance, does not amount to provision of financial services.

Conclusion: Leasing of the factory in these circumstances did not fall within taxable banking and other financial services, and the demand was unsustainable.

Final Conclusion: The Revenue failed to establish that the respondents were providing taxable financial leasing or equipment leasing services, so the appeals did not merit interference.

Ratio Decidendi: Mere leasing of a factory and its assets by a manufacturing company, without the attributes of financial leasing or lease-finance activity, is not taxable as banking and other financial services.

---