Compensation for commercial use of machinery is taxable as income when it arises from exploitation of the asset, not capital transfer.

Compensation received for the commercial use of machinery was treated as taxable income because it arose from exploitation of a partnership asset held in common, not from a capital settlement or transfer of the machinery's value. The receipt was paid in full settlement of a claim specifically for use of the machinery by the mills, and was therefore assessable as income from other sources. It was not a mere adjustment of capital value or a casual non-taxable receipt, so the amount was held liable to income-tax.

---

---

Issues: Whether the sum received as compensation for the use of machinery was income liable to income-tax.

Analysis: The receipt was not part of a capital settlement for the value of the machinery, but was paid in full settlement of a claim specifically made for compensation for the use of the machinery by the mills. Even though the partnership had not carried on business, the amount represented profits arising from the user of a partnership asset or an asset held in common, and was therefore assessable as income under the head of income from other sources. The receipt was neither a mere adjustment of capital value nor a casual non-taxable receipt.

Conclusion: The amount of Rs. 75,000 was income liable to income-tax and the question was answered in the affirmative against the assessee.

Ratio Decidendi: Compensation received for the commercial use of a capital asset, where it arises from the exploitation of that asset and not from a capital transfer, is taxable as income.

---