Partnership reconstitution and gift tax: reduction in a partner's share is not a gift when incoming partners contribute capital and support the business.

On reconstitution of a partnership firm, reduction in an existing partner's share to admit new partners who contribute capital and strengthen the business is not, by itself, a taxable gift under the Gift-tax Act. Goodwill forms part of the firm's assets, and a partner's interest may extend to it, but a transfer is a gift only if it is voluntary and without consideration. The Revenue must prove absence of consideration, and where the incoming partners provide capital and business support, the reduced share is supported by consideration in money's worth. The reduced partnership interest was therefore not a gift and no gift-tax liability arose.

---

---

Issues: Whether the reduction in a partner's share on reconstitution of a firm, when new partners introduced share capital, constituted a taxable gift under the Gift-tax Act.

Analysis: Goodwill is an asset of the firm and a partner's share may extend to it. However, a transaction is a gift only if the transfer is voluntary and without consideration. On reconstitution of a partnership, the burden lies on the Revenue to show absence of consideration. Where incoming partners introduce capital and thereby strengthen the firm and promote its business, the reduced share of the existing partner is supported by sufficient consideration in money's worth. Such reduction in share cannot, by itself, be treated as a gift merely because a portion of the partnership interest is allotted to new partners.

Conclusion: The transfer was not a gift and the assessee was not liable to gift-tax.

Ratio Decidendi: On reconstitution of a firm, reduction in an existing partner's share to admit new partners who contribute capital and otherwise support the business is not a taxable gift unless the Revenue proves that the transfer was without consideration.

---