2006 (1) TMI 631 - AT - Service Tax

Tribunal Upholds Remand Order in Service Tax Case; Appellant's Challenge Dismissed

Commissioner of C. Ex., Meerut-I Versus Amba Steels

Commissioner of C. Ex., Meerut-I Versus Amba Steels - 2007 (5) S.T.R. 275 (Tri. - Del.) Issues:Challenge to order of remand by Commissioner (Appeals) in Service Tax case.Analysis:In this case, the appellant contested the order of remand issued by the Commissioner (Appeals) regarding a Service Tax matter. The adjudicating authority had demanded Service Tax of Rs. 5,75,000 from the respondent along with interest and penalties under various sections of the Finance Act, 1994. The penalties were imposed due to the respondent receiving an amount in the form of ad hoc advance, which was considered as 'Other Income.' The appellate authority found faults in the adjudicating authority's decision, stating that relevant Circulars and judgments were not considered, and the order was deemed as a non-speaking order. Consequently, the matter was remanded to the adjudicating authority for a fresh decision after providing the assessee with a proper opportunity for a personal hearing.The main contention raised was the power of the Commissioner (Appeals) to remand the matter. This argument was dismissed based on a decision by the Gujarat High Court in the case of Commissioner of Central Excise, Ahmedabad-I v. Medico Labs. The High Court held that the Commissioner (Appeals) indeed possessed the authority to remand a case while deciding an appeal, as confirmed by the Supreme Court's decision in Union of India v. Umesh Dhaimode. The Tribunal also cited its own order from a previous case where it followed the same principle, emphasizing the Commissioner (Appeals)'s power to confirm, modify, annul decisions, or make a remand that effectively annuls the decision. Therefore, the Tribunal found no merit in the appeal and dismissed it accordingly.