Conditional waiver of pre-deposit in service tax dispute granted subject to deposit of tax, interest and penalties

In a service tax dispute, the Tribunal declined full waiver of pre-deposit because the assessee had conceded the tax demand and interest, and the record indicated undervaluation of taxable consideration by excluding royalty paid to the franchisor. Finding no substantial error in the adjudication order, it granted only conditional relief. The assessee was directed to deposit the assessed tax, interest, part of the penalty, and the fixed penalty under section 77, with waiver of the remaining pre-deposit and stay of recovery operative only on compliance.

---

---

Issues: Whether waiver of pre-deposit and stay of further proceedings should be granted in a service tax matter where the demand and interest were not seriously disputed, but the penalty and recovery were sought to be kept in abeyance.

Analysis: The Tribunal noted that the assessee had conceded the service tax demand and the corresponding interest. It also recorded that the assessee had undervalued the taxable consideration by excluding royalty paid to the franchisor while filing returns, and that no substantial error was apparent in the adjudication order. In these circumstances, full waiver of pre-deposit was declined. However, the Tribunal balanced the matter by granting conditional relief, requiring deposit of the assessed tax, interest, part of the penalty, and the fixed penalty under section 77, failing which the waiver would stand rescinded.

Conclusion: Conditional waiver of pre-deposit and stay of recovery were granted, subject to compliance with the deposit directions.

---