Valuation of large acquired land: small sale instances need development deductions when fixing market value.

For valuation of a large tract of acquired land with development potential, small sale instances are not a safe direct guide. Market value must be assessed from the standpoint of a prudent willing purchaser, and where the land is large, undeveloped, and requires roads, drainage and civic amenities, substantial deductions for development charges may be justified. The difference in size between the acquired land and the exemplar plots, together with possible statutory restrictions on development, supported the deduction applied. On that basis, the 60% deduction was upheld and the compensation fixed by the High Court was left undisturbed.

---

---

Issues: Whether, in fixing compensation for acquisition of a large tract of land, the High Court was justified in relying on small sale instances and deducting 60% towards development and other considerations.

Analysis: The land acquired was a large extent situated away from the municipal limits, and the sale deeds relied upon related to small plots. In valuing large agricultural or undeveloped land with building potential, the Court must assess market value from the standpoint of a prudent willing purchaser and not on conjecture. Small developed plots are not a safe direct guide for valuing a large block of land, and where the land requires formation of roads, drainage and civic amenities, appropriate deductions for development charges are permissible. The possibility of statutory restrictions on development and the difference in size between the acquired land and the exemplars were relevant factors supporting a substantial deduction.

Conclusion: The deduction of 60% was justified and the compensation fixed by the High Court was upheld against the appellant.

Final Conclusion: The appeal failed and the award of compensation as determined by the High Court remained undisturbed.

Ratio Decidendi: For valuation of a large tract of land with development potential, small comparable sales cannot be adopted without appropriate deductions for development and amenity requirements, and market value must be fixed on the basis of what a prudent willing purchaser would pay.

---