Intention in share and securities dealings determines whether losses are business losses or capital losses.

Losses from transactions in shares and Government securities were held to be capital losses, not deductible business losses under the Income-tax Act, 1922. The Court applied the test of intention, to be inferred from the facts and surrounding circumstances, and distinguished business dealings from capital investment and casual, non-recurring receipts. As the assessee had made only a few sales, generally held the securities for long periods, and acquired them mainly for dividends and interest rather than trading or speculation, the transactions were treated as investment activity. The Court also declined to reopen the factual findings of the tax authorities and found no error of law in their conclusion.

---

---

Issues: Whether losses arising from the purchase and sale of shares and Government securities were deductible as business losses or were capital losses not allowable in computing income under the Income-tax Act, 1922.

Analysis: The assessee sought to treat losses on shares and Government Promissory Notes as deductible business losses. The Court held that the statutory definition of "business" is wide, but it must be distinguished from capital investment and from receipts of a casual and non-recurring nature. The decisive test was the intention with which the purchases were made, to be gathered from the facts and surrounding circumstances. On the facts found, the assessee had made few sales, the securities and shares were generally held for long periods, and the purchases were directed to earning dividends and interest rather than to trading or speculation. The Court also noted that it could not reopen the findings of fact recorded by the income-tax authorities and found no error of law in the conclusion drawn from those facts.

Conclusion: The losses were capital losses and not admissible deductions as business losses.

Final Conclusion: The application failed because the disputed transactions were held to be investment activities rather than a business of dealing in shares or securities.

Ratio Decidendi: Whether dealings in shares or securities amount to business depends on the intention and pattern of transactions as shown by the facts; isolated or infrequent sales after long holding periods ordinarily indicate capital investment rather than a trading venture.

---