Proportionality in conviction-based dismissal: removal from service for a minor offence was held excessive and unjustified.

Rule 19 of the Madhya Pradesh Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1966 permits the disciplinary authority to consider the circumstances of a conviction-based penalty, but it does not require dismissal in every case. The authority must act fairly, justly and reasonably, considering the nature of the misconduct, the gravity of the offence, the employee's post, and whether the conduct involves moral turpitude or a heinous act. On those principles, removal from service for a conviction for simple hurt, where the sentence was reduced to fine and the employee held the lowest cadre post, was held disproportionate and unjustified. Judicial review was therefore available on proportionality grounds.

---

---

Issues: Whether the penalty of removal from service imposed on a government servant, convicted for a simple offence, was excessive and liable to be interfered with in judicial review.

Analysis: Rule 19 of the Madhya Pradesh Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1966 empowers the disciplinary authority to consider the circumstances of the case where penalty follows conviction on a criminal charge, but it does not mandate dismissal in every such case. The authority must exercise its discretion fairly, justly and reasonably, having regard to the nature of the misconduct, the gravity of the offence, the employee's position, and whether the offence involves moral turpitude or a heinous act. The conviction here was for simple hurt, the sentence was reduced to fine, and the employee held the lowest cadre post. The punishment was therefore found to be disproportionate. The governing standard of review was also treated as one of proportionality rather than a mechanical application of Wednesbury unreasonableness.

Conclusion: The dismissal from service was held to be unjustified and excessive, and interference with the order was warranted in favour of the respondent.

---