Circumstantial evidence can justify rejection of accounts and best-judgment estimation of turnover and profits under income tax law.

Circumstantial evidence and surrounding business facts may justify rejection of an assessee's books where the accounts do not reflect the true state of business. Omission of substantial transactions, including property purchases, rent receipts, litigation and other asset-related dealings, was treated as material supporting disbelief of the records. The relevant term "evidence" was taken to include circumstantial material, and past sales history, steady overheads and an earlier disclosed profit rate were used to support a best-judgment estimate of turnover and profits under the Income-tax Act. The rejection of accounts and estimation of sales and profits were upheld on the material available on record.

---

---

Issues: Whether there was material justifying rejection of the assessee's accounts and estimation of sales and profits under the Indian Income-tax Act.

Analysis: The omission from the account books of substantial transactions, including purchase of immovable property, receipt of rent, expenditure on litigation, and other property purchases, furnished material to conclude that the books did not reflect the true state of the assessee's business. The word "evidence" in the relevant provision was held to include circumstantial evidence, and the past sales history, together with the steady overheads and the assessee's own disclosed profit rate in an earlier year, provided material for fixing the sales at Rs. 1,50,000 and applying a flat profit rate of 15 per cent.

Conclusion: The rejection of the accounts and the estimates of sales and profits were upheld; the assessee's application for reference was not allowed.

Final Conclusion: The decision sustained the income-tax authorities' power to reject unreliable accounts and to make a reasonable estimate of turnover and profits on the basis of material available on record.

Ratio Decidendi: Circumstantial evidence and surrounding business facts may constitute sufficient material to reject accounts and support a best-judgment estimation of sales and profits under the Income-tax Act.

---