Borrowed capital used for partnership investment is deductible, but personal account-preparation expenses are not allowable

Interest paid on money debited from a banking account and applied as share capital in a firm was deductible, because the amount was treated in substance as capital borrowed for investment in business. The presence of other funds in the account did not alter the borrowing character of the amount actually debited and used. Audit fees and stationery expenses incurred for preparing or maintaining the assessee's personal accounts were not deductible against share income, as they were not shown to arise from the income-producing activity and were not otherwise authorised by the statute.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether the interest paid on amounts debited from the assessee's banking account and invested as share capital in a firm was deductible against the share income under the Income-tax Act, 1922. (ii) Whether audit fees and stationery expenses incurred by the assessee for maintaining or preparing her personal accounts were deductible against such share income.

Issue (i): Whether the interest paid on amounts debited from the assessee's banking account and invested as share capital in a firm was deductible against the share income under the Income-tax Act, 1922.

Analysis: The decisive question was whether the sum invested in the partnership had in substance been borrowed for the purpose of making the investment. The existence of other funds in the assessee's account did not ate the borrowing character of the amount actually debited and applied for the investment. The material showed that, under the assessee's directions, the amount of Rs. 90,000 was debited in the banking account and was invested in the firm. Interest paid on capital borrowed for the purpose of business falls within the statutory allowance.

Conclusion: The interest payment was deductible and the answer on this issue was in favour of the assessee.

Issue (ii): Whether audit fees and stationery expenses incurred by the assessee for maintaining or preparing her personal accounts were deductible against such share income.

Analysis: These expenses were not shown to have been incurred in the business from which the income arose. The share income had already been ascertained in the firm's assessment, and the expenses claimed were in the nature of personal expenditure connected with the assessee's own accounts and tax compliance. No provision of the Act justified treating them as allowable deductions.

Conclusion: The audit fees and stationery expenses were not deductible and the answer on this issue was against the assessee.

Final Conclusion: The claim succeeded only in respect of the interest payment, while the claims for audit fees and stationery expenses failed.

Ratio Decidendi: Interest on a borrowing actually applied for investment in a business or partnership is deductible as capital borrowed for the purpose of business, but personal or account-preparation expenses are not allowable unless specifically authorised by the statute.

---