Multifunction parboiling machinery classified under Chapter Heading 8419.00; single-function test under Section XVI Note 4 rejected.

Parboiling and drying plant and machinery performing multiple functions, including parboiling, cleaning, sorting and grading, was held classifiable under Chapter Heading 8419.00 rather than Chapter Heading 84.37. Note 4 to Section XVI was found inapplicable because it applies only to machines made up of components working together to achieve a single clearly defined function. As the heat exchanger was used for parboiling and the equipment was not confined to one defined function, classification under Heading 84.37 was rejected and the Revenue's reliance on the HSN explanatory notes was accepted. The impugned classification order was set aside and the Revenue's appeal succeeded.

---

---

Issues: Whether the parboiling and drying plant and machinery was classifiable under Chapter Heading 8419.00 or Chapter Heading 84.37.

Analysis: The machinery was found to perform more than one function, namely parboiling as well as cleaning, sorting and grading. Note 4 to Section XVI was held inapplicable because it covers machines consisting of individual components intended to contribute together to a clearly defined function. Since the heat exchanger was used for parboiling and the machine was not confined to a single clearly defined function, the claim for classification under Heading 84.37 was rejected and the Revenue's reliance on the relevant HSN explanatory notes was accepted.

Conclusion: The machinery was classifiable under Chapter Heading 8419.00 and not under Chapter Heading 84.37, in favour of Revenue.

Final Conclusion: The impugned classification order was set aside and the Revenue's appeal succeeded.

Ratio Decidendi: A machine performing more than one function cannot be classified by applying Note 4 to Section XVI where that note is confined to components contributing together to a single clearly defined function.

---