Inter-State sale classification of software transactions set aside and remanded for fresh factual assessment.

Assessment orders treating software-related transactions with Bangalore-based clients as inter-State sales under the Central Sales Tax Act were set aside because the authorities had relied on a conclusory approach without examining the contractual documents, work orders, nature of services rendered, deployment of personnel at client premises, or clauses dealing with inputs and intellectual property rights. The authorities also failed to consider the contention that the transactions had already been subjected to service tax. As these issues required factual inquiry not properly undertaken below, they could not be finally resolved in writ jurisdiction. The matters were remitted to the assessing authority for fresh assessment in accordance with law.

---

---

Issues: Whether the assessment orders treating the petitioner's transactions with Bangalore-based clients as inter-State sales of software under the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956 were sustainable, and whether the matters required remand for fresh assessment.

Analysis: The assessment orders were found to have proceeded on a conclusory basis without a proper examination of the contractual documents, the work orders, the nature of the services rendered, or the petitioner's contention that its personnel were deployed at the clients' premises and that any development, if at all, occurred at Bangalore. The authorities also failed to deal with the effect of the contractual clauses on inputs and intellectual property rights and did not consider the petitioner's plea that the transactions were already subjected to service tax. Since these matters involved factual inquiries that had not been properly addressed by the assessing and appellate authorities, they could not be finally resolved in writ jurisdiction.

Conclusion: The assessment orders were unsustainable for want of proper consideration of the material and were set aside, with the matters remitted to the assessing authority for fresh assessment in accordance with law.

---